HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission 2012-04-10 Minutes
IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBER OF THE CITY OF SAN RAFAEL, April 10, 2012
Regular Meeting
San Rafael Planning Commission Minutes
For a complete video of this meeting, go to http://www.cityofsanrafael.org/meetings
CALL TO ORDER
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
RECORDING OF MEMBERS PRESENT AND ABSENT
Commissioners Present: Maribeth Lang
Larry Paul
Charles Pick
Jack Robertson
Dan Sonnet
Viktoriya Wise, Chair
Commissioner Absent: Kate Colin
Staff Present: Raffi Boloyan, Principal Planner
Steve Stafford, Associate Planner
APPROVAL OR REVISION OF ORDER OF AGENDA ITEMS
None
PUBLIC NOTIFICATION OF MEETING PROCEDURES
URGENT COMMUNICATION
None
CONSENT CALENDAR
1. Minutes, February 14, 2012
Dan Sonnet moved and Jack Robertson seconded to approve Minutes as presented with vote as follows:
AYES: Charlie Pick, Dan Sonnet, Jack Robertson, Viktoriya Wise,Chair
NOES: None
ABSTAIN: Larry Paul, Maribeth Lang
ABSENT: Kate Colin
NEW BUSINESS
2. 1024 Las Raposas Road - Appeal of staff's approval on March 1, 2012 of an Environmental
and Design Review Permit (ED12-011) to allow a 7.5'-tall, replacement fence along the
common, side property line between 1014 and 1024 Las Raposas Rd.; APN: 178 -025-19;
Single-Family Residential - Eichler and Alliance Home Overlay (R5-EA) District; Beverly
Goodwin, owner/applicant; Coach Bella and Claudette Ferriter, Chase and Chad Sambell,
appellants; File No.: AP12-002. Project Planner: Steve Stafford
Charlie Pick moved and Larry Paul seconded to Approve Motion to deny appeal and uphold staff's
decision to approve fence height.
AYES: Maribeth Lang, Larry Paul, Charlie Pick, Dan Sonnet, Jack Robertson, Viktoriya Wise,
Chair
NOES: None
ABSENT: Kate Colin
3. 190 El Cerrito Ave (Untermann Subdivision) - Request for Rezoning, Tentative Map and
Environmental & Design Review Permit to allow; 1) the subdivision of the single 6.24 -acre
hillside parcel into two lots, with the existing single family home at 190 El Cerrito
remaining on a 3.24-acre parcel and a new single family home proposed on a new 3.0-acre
parcel; 2) Rezoning of the site from a Planned Development to a revised Planned
Development to reflect the proposed project; and 3) conceptual review for compliance
with hillside guidelines the design and siting for the proposed new single fam ily
residence; APN: 011-121-10; Planned Development - Hillside Overlay (PD-H) District; Tom
and Merrie Untermann, owners; Al Cornwell/CSW Stuber-Stroeh, applicant; File No(s).:
TS11-004, ZC11-003 and ED11-047. Project Planner: Raffi Boloyan
Larry Paul moved and Jack Robertson seconded to approve Resolution to adopt Mitigated Negative
Declaration (MND) and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) with revisions as
recommended by Commission. The vote is as follows:
AYES: Maribeth Lang, Larry Paul, Charlie Pick, Dan Sonnet, Chair, Viktoriya Wise, Jack
Robertson
NOES: None
ABSENT: Kate Colin
Larry Paul moved to adopt the Re-zoning Resolution with revision as presented by staff, but motion failed,
as there was no Second to the Motion.
Charlie Pick moved and Jack Robertson seconded to adopt the Re-zoning resolution with revision as
presented by staff and to include revision to Attachment B Item 2, F Number 5 to read as follows:
“5. The area between the front property line (street) and the front of the building may contain: 1)
Minimal improvements essential for vehicular access and parking, 2) pedestrian access, 3) necessary
residential services such as postal mail and garbage collection, 4) needed utility and drainage facilities.”
Also,retain last sentence of Item 5. In addition, modify Item 2 of the resolution in items a and b.
Commissioner Paul stated he would vote “no” only because of revision to PD section
2.F.5.
AYES: Maribeth Lang, Charlie Pick, Dan Sonnet, Jack Robertson, Viktoriya Wise, Chair
NOES: Larry Paul
ABSENT: Kate Colin
Jack Robertson moved and Charlie Pick seconded to recommend adoption of the Tentative Parcel Map
resolution with revisions as presented by staff and to include modifications to points similar to those made
in the previous re-zoning Resolution to Tentative Map conditions #7 and #12 as follows:
Modify Exhibit 2C-5, Tentative Map Condition #7, subpoint C and Tentative Map Condition #12 subpoint
C modify to reflect four points of allowable encroac hment. The vote is as follows:
Commissioner Paul stated he would vote “No” solely due to the change in the conditions of approval.
AYES: Maribeth Lang, Charlie Pick, Dan Sonnet, Chair, Viktoriya Wise, Jack Robertson
NOES: Larry Paul
ABSENT: Kate Colin
DIRECTOR'S REPORT
Director Report was made
COMMISSION COMMUNICATION
ADJOURNMENT:
___________________________________
ANNE DERRICK, Administrative Assistant III
APPROVED THIS_____DAY____OF_______, 2012
_____________________________________
Viktoriya Wise, Chair